A Root Grows in Winona

By Staff
article image

4735 W. 5th Winona, Minnesota 55987

There is life in those ‘Old Roots’ thanks to the efforts
of Edward Chick. The Winona, Minnesota native has once again
brought to life a new half-scale model. Through his multi-talented
dedication to a dream, a new -scale Root & V and ervoort
upright is now a reality. The engine is scaled from a 4 HP upright.
The engine came into Ed’s possession through a trade. I
remember the day when he picked the engine up. It was a very cold
Good Friday. I was involved in the trade because my father needed
some help with his heavy hobby.

The original Root was complete except for the cooling tank and
screen, skids and cart. The engine (all 1485 lbs. of it) was loaded
into our pickup with the aid of a front-end loader. The job of
getting the Root off the truck was not as easy as getting it on the
truck. The engine had to be disassembled. When the head was
removed, we found out why there was no paint to be found on the
engine. At one time the engine had been stored for a long period of
time in a creek bed. On the top of the piston there were 6 inches
of mud, and the remains of a small minnow, and a few snails to keep
the valves company. Over the years the badly necked valves, and the
pitted seats, and guides had formed quite an attachment for one
another. The valves and guides had to be replaced. The seats were
reground, and fitted with the valves from a 327 Chevy. At one time
the spring water was allowed to freeze in the cooling jacket and
head causing them to become slightly bulged. When the head and
jacket were welded, attention was turned to the bore. The interior
of the cylinder above where the piston had stopped moving so long
ago was very pitted. The cylinder was honed and the rings freed,
and seemed to be in pretty good shape. Disassembly continued and
work increased. It seemed as if every part on the engine needed
work. All of the pins and bushings on the Root were replaced; the
crankshaft was metalized and turned. The rod had a twist which
meant that the main bearings had to be replaced.

All of the exterior parts were badly rusted and sorely in need
of a friend. The igniter was one solid lump which took well over a
week to rework (most of the time spent in getting it apart). The
thought of those first smoke rings just keeps a person going!

While the Root was apart and covering much of the shop, Ed
started the model. The first step in building any model begins with
the measurement and drawing of each engine piece. The Root & V
and ervoort that was being built was to be an exact copy of the
engine that R & V  built for the Deere & Webber
Company of Minneapolis. The engine was sold under the name of
Reindeer Engines; these facts were made known to us by the
beautifully preserved brass nameplate mounted on the cylinder.
Nameplates always help greatly in the restoration of any engine,
and the Root was no exception.

The fuel tank was cast into the sub-base, cast iron on all sides
and therefore sound. The fuel pump was made of brass; however, the
two check balls that made the green lump a fuel pump had long since
disappeared. The carb on the Root was broken from freezing, and
when the needle valve was turned it broke off also. A person can
really get quite good at welding cast iron after awhile. When all
is said and done, that first pop is worth all of the work.

The actual building of a scale model out of cast iron requires
the builder to make two engines. The first is made of wood, which
later becomes the patterns from which the castings are made. The
second is the actual engine, made from the castings. There is also
one thing that must be mentioned. You need a foundry that is
willing to let you fail for awhile before all of your patterns work
just the way they should. Very often more than one pattern is
required for each part. The cylinder, for example, used three
patterns alone. The pattern work for the R & V took Ed
over a year to develop a set that would give the high quality
castings that are required to become parts for one of Ed’s

When making a half-scale model, one often runs into a number of
problems. Each part that is scaled down presents its own headaches.
The carb was very time consuming; when the scale was cut down the
volume through the throat was cut drastically. To get a carb that
would deliver the proper volume to run the engine and yet maintain
a half-scale appearance was very difficult. The carb is a constant
level type which is pump fed; excess fuel spills over a small dam
in the carb and returns to the fuel tank by a secondary fuel

As Ed worked on the Root he found that the majority of the
engine could be built on the turning lathe. The lathe was used to
machine all major castings with the exception of sub-base, rod, and
head. Most of the remaining work was completed on a drill press and
small milling machine.

When a person scales down a 1400 pound engine, you might expect
that the model might weigh alot also. The half-scale Root tips the
scales at just over 125 lbs. Ed feels that the weight is the key to
the engine’s ability to run so smoothly at 375 rpms for hours
on end. His Root was fitted with a brass cooling tank and screen.
The engine ran the first time that he attempted to run it. It did
take awhile to get it to run the way he wanted it to before he
would take it to any shows. When all is said and done the Root
& V and ervoort is truly a remarkable engine. The Root can be
seen any day sitting next to one of Ed’s -scale Fuller &
John sons. The F & J’s will very shortly be pulling model
pump jacks, and saw rigs, at shows throughout the Midwest this

What does Ed plan on taking on next? He is currently building
two models. A full-size Franklin engine, and a half-size Fairbanks
& Morse upright modeled after a 4 HP. He has a third model in
the works: a Mi-scale Domestic side shaft. It looks as if Ed will
be busy for the next little while with these three engines; kits do
take time! I would like to wish my father all the best in these
projects. When in the neighborhood, stop in and see Ed. He is
always willing to run one or all of his little beauties for anyone
who loves the smell of smoke rings.

Gas Engine Magazine
Gas Engine Magazine
Preserving the History of Internal Combustion Engines